John Trop, Esq.

John Trop, Esq.

Partner, Syracuse

John Trop has 37 years of experience as a trial lawyer in New York State. Before joining Sugarman Law Firm in November of 2025, John served as Director of Client Legal Services at Allstate Insurance Company, where he managed the entire New York State Allstate Staff Counsel legal practice.  The Law Office of John Trop included: 140 lawyers, 10 Lead Counsel Leaders, 186 Support Staff (including 67 offshore in India and Northern Ireland) and 7 Support Staff Leaders.

John Trop Law Office managed an active caseload of more than 82,000 cases and opened and retained over 77,000 new cases annually, primarily involving auto, homeowners, and special investigations in personal injury protection. As Managing Attorney, John oversaw weekly trial activity across both downstate and upstate New York, giving him a unique perspective on litigation in all sixty-two counties.

John is a strategic, purposeful trial lawyer with deep expertise in litigation management, legal operations, and insurance defense trial advocacy. He is a proven leader with a demonstrated ability to drive operational efficiency and improve litigation outcomes. An enthusiastic advocate for data-driven legal strategies and talent development, John consistently delivers measurable results.

John began his legal career with the United States Attorney’s Office for the Northern District of Georgia, representing the United States in trial courts and gaining foundational experience in litigation and courtroom advocacy.

He is a former member of the NYS Bar Association Professional Discipline Committee and a Lecturer in Trial Practice. John is also an Advocate Member of the American Board of Trial Advocates which only admits members based on trial verdict results. John served on the Onondaga County Bar Association Judiciary and Ethics Committees. In addition, he served on the Visiting Nurses of Central New York, Inc. Board for 14 years, including as Board Chairperson. John is also a former Board member of the CCH Home and Palliative Care Inc.

John resides in Pompey, NY with his wife, Julie. They have three daughters: Alex, Mary, and Sally.

  • Insurance Defense
  • Personal Injury
  • Insurance Coverage
  • Municipal Defense

Education
  • Emory University School of Law (LL.M – Master of Laws, Litigation)
  • Ohio Northern University School of Law (Juris Doctor) Law Review
  • Syracuse University (Bachelor of Science, Business Management)
Admissions
  • New York State Courts
Proud Supporter of Make-A-Wish
The information on this site is not legal advice, it is Attorney Advertising intended to educate potential clients about their need for legal advice and assist them in obtaining a lawyer appropriate for those needs. Use of this site does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case is different and every person should consult a lawyer to asses their particular case. If you think our firm can assist you please contact us for a consultation. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.